Truck wrecks don’t behave like ordinary car crashes, and their settlements don’t either. When an 80,000-pound tractor-trailer tangles with a sedan on 75 or 380, the forces, the injuries, and the legal exposure all scale up. A seasoned McKinney personal injury lawyer doesn’t start with a formula; we start with a story grounded in evidence. The final number is the output of a disciplined investigation, careful medical analysis, and strategic leverage against the layers of insurance and corporate risk that come with commercial trucking.
This is a walk-through of how that valuation really happens, using the same framework I use when I sit down with a new client, a stack of records, and a whiteboard.
The first valuation: liability before damages
Before we talk dollars, we talk fault. In Texas, proportionate responsibility is the gatekeeper. If a jury decides you were 20 percent at fault for the crash, your damages get reduced by 20 percent. Cross 50 percent and you collect nothing. That’s why a McKinney injury lawyer will burn hours early on reconstructing what happened and locking down liability.
The facts that move the needle aren’t always dramatic. Yes, we look for the big issues like a rear-end collision or a police citation. But the decisive evidence often sits in the gray area of negligence: a trucker who exceeded hours-of-service limits by two hours because a dispatcher pushed him, a maintenance log showing delayed brake replacement, a missing 30-minute rest break that left the driver fatigued. Those details can flip a close case on fault and increase value by six figures without changing a single medical bill.
We typically pull the following threads: the electronic logging device (ELD) data that tracks hours; the truck’s engine control module download; dashcam or forward-facing video; bills of lading; dispatch notes; driver qualification file; and the motor carrier’s safety history from FMCSA. A McKinney auto accident lawyer who knows Texas discovery practice will get a preservation letter out within days and push for a Rule 196 inspection to keep the evidence from going stale.
Once liability looks solid, we begin quantifying the claim. But the fault analysis never truly stops, because every percentage point matters to the final check.
The medical core: injuries, trajectory, and permanence
Experienced lawyers value claims from the injury outward. Two cases can show the same ER bill and end with wildly different results because one client made a full recovery in four months and the other client faces a lifetime of neuropathic pain.
The first pass on medical value leans on three pillars: objective findings, functional impact, and medical prognosis.
Objective findings mean imaging and measurable tests: CT scans showing intracranial bleeding, MRIs with disc protrusions impinging nerve roots, EMG studies confirming radiculopathy, range-of-motion deficits documented by a treating doctor. Insurers discount reports that only recite pain complaints. They pay attention when a surgeon writes that a tear won’t heal without arthroscopy or a neurosurgeon documents cervical myelopathy.
Functional impact shows up in the day-to-day. A 38-year-old welder who can’t lift more than 15 pounds and needs to change careers has greater loss than a desk worker with the same MRI. We document work restrictions, missed milestones in physical therapy, and the ways a client’s life constricted: the HOA board volunteer who stopped attending meetings because she can’t sit for an hour, the dad who can’t coach Little League because of shoulder instability.
Prognosis separates temporary harm from permanent impairment. If a client needs a fusion in five years as adjacent segment disease progresses, that future surgery belongs in the valuation today. We don’t guess. We ask treating physicians for a medical probability opinion and cost-of-care estimates, then cross-check them against CPT coding and local hospital fee schedules.
Economic damages: what we can count
On paper, economic damages look straightforward. In practice, they require discipline. Adjusters scrutinize numbers and pounce on sloppiness, so we build from contemporaneous documentation.
Medical expenses start with the gross billed charges, not the reduced amounts insurance may pay. Texas law lets juries hear only the paid or owed amounts, so we map the bills to the actual numbers a provider will accept. For clients with health insurance, we track contractual adjustments and liens. For those treating on letters of protection, we analyze reasonableness by comparing charges to fair-market rates in Collin County and Dallas medical districts. A McKinney car accident lawyer who’s been around the block will anticipate the defense expert’s reasonableness critique and assemble local pricing data to defend the charges.
Lost earnings subdivide into past and future. Past loss is payroll records, W-2s, 1099s, and tax returns. We collaborate with employers to confirm missed hours and document loss of bonuses or commissions. Future loss means capacity, not just a calendar. A 12 percent permanent impairment rating can materially change a tradesperson’s lifetime earnings trajectory. When the numbers get big or the career implications are nuanced, we bring in a vocational rehabilitation expert and an economist who can apply the right growth rates, discount rates, and work-life expectancy tables. They convert limitations into dollars over time, with a methodology that holds up at trial.
Out-of-pocket costs tend to get overlooked until late in the process, which is a mistake. Transportation for medical appointments, home modifications after a knee reconstruction, replacement services like childcare or lawn care while a client is immobilized — we gather receipts and sworn statements to keep the record complete.
Non-economic damages: pain, loss, and credibility
This is the hardest category to price and the most sensitive to how the story is told. There’s no ledger line for a night of unbroken sleep you no longer Thompson Law McKinney truck accident lawyer get or for a marriage strained by chronic pain. Texas juries can award for pain, suffering, mental anguish, physical impairment, and disfigurement. The question isn’t whether these exist — in serious truck crashes, they do — but how convincingly you can prove their effect.
Adjusters informally model non-economic harm as a multiple of specials or as a per diem, but those heuristics are crude. We push jurors and carriers to think in human terms: six months of waking at 3 a.m. with shooting pain down the arm, 200 physical therapy sessions, the screwdriver you can no longer grip, the wedding ring you stopped wearing because of swelling. We corroborate with third-party witnesses — a spouse, a foreman, a softball teammate — not because they’re dramatic, but because they provide unvarnished baseline and delta: what life looked like before and after.
Scarring and disfigurement deserve their own thought. A 3-inch facial laceration on a 26-year-old professional can eclipse the medical bills in value. We photograph progression over time and consult with plastic surgeons about revision options and costs.
The client’s credibility saturates this category. Consistent reporting, diligent therapy attendance, honest acknowledgment of improvement where it exists — these traits move numbers more than any formula. A McKinney personal injury lawyer invests time coaching clients on documentation and testimony because telling the truth well is a skill, and it pays.
Multiparty and multilayer insurance: the chessboard
Truck cases rarely involve a single policy. A motor carrier might carry a $1 million primary policy with a large national insurer, a $2 million excess layer with a different carrier, and a contractual indemnity agreement with a shipper whose own insurer is watching from the sideline. The tractor could be owned by one company and the trailer by another. A broker might have directed the load, adding another defendant and another policy.
Why does this matter? Settlement dynamics change when primary limits are threatened. Primary carriers fight harder below limits and shift posture swiftly when exposure creeps above their layer. We track reserves, ask the right questions during adjuster calls, and read the tea leaves on whether excess has been notified. If the defense moves to bifurcate trials or shield the motor carrier’s corporate conduct evidence, that’s a tell that they see nuclear verdict risk.
We also watch for state and federal minimums. Interstate carriers typically must carry at least $750,000, often $1 million. But local intrastate carriers can be insured for less and still legally operate. If the damages outstrip insurance, we look for assets, other negligent actors, and insurance loopholes such as MCS-90 endorsements that may expand recovery in specific scenarios.
Comparative fault and road conditions: the local angle
McKinney roads have their own hazards. Construction zones along 380, tight merges onto 121, and short on-ramps create setups where both drivers make split-second choices. Defense lawyers will argue that a car darted into a truck’s blind spot or braked suddenly. We counter by testing whether the trucker followed the space-management rules taught in CDL training and whether speed was adjusted for traffic and weather. We subpoena dashcam footage from nearby businesses when intersections like Virginia Parkway and Hardin carry cameras aimed at their parking lots, not just the roadway. That collateral footage has salvaged more than one “no one saw it” case.
Comparative fault analysis gets granular. Tire scuffs and yaw marks on the asphalt, contact-point height on the vehicle, damage patterns that reveal angle and speed — all feed a reconstruction that either limits the client’s percentage or anchors it to zero. The difference between 10 percent and 30 percent fault in a $1 million case is $200,000. We invest accordingly.
Medical liens, subrogation, and net recovery
Gross settlement numbers only tell part of the story. The client’s net matters most. Health insurers assert subrogation rights, Medicare demands reimbursement, hospitals file liens, and workers’ comp carriers stand in line. Skilled handling of these claims can change the client’s take-home by tens of thousands.
The playbook varies. ERISA plans can be aggressive, but some are riddled with plan-language gaps that let us argue for reductions. Medicare reduces its lien proportionally when comparative fault is at issue and will entertain hardship arguments. Hospital liens attach only to reasonable and necessary charges related to the accident, and they’re limited to the first 100 days of care under Texas law. A McKinney injury lawyer who negotiates these routinely knows where leverage exists, when to bring in a lien-resolution vendor, and how to structure the settlement to minimize friction.
We model the net as we negotiate the gross. If a carrier bumps an offer by $20,000 but Medicare wants $18,000 more back, the “increase” doesn’t help the client. We keep a live spreadsheet of medical balances, lien claims, attorney fees, and case costs so there are no surprises.
Valuation methods that carriers and juries respect
There’s no single calculator, but there are methods that keep you honest and persuasive.
Comparable verdicts and settlements anchor expectations. We pull North Texas results with similar injuries, venues, and liability posture. A Collin County jury tends to behave differently than a Dallas County jury in the same fact pattern. A shoulder labrum tear with arthroscopic repair and good recovery has repeatedly landed in the low to mid six figures when liability is solid. A cervical fusion with permanent work restrictions might break seven figures if corporate misconduct evidence is strong. These aren’t promises; they’re guideposts that keep negotiations tethered to reality.
Life-care plans make the future tangible. When injuries are permanent, we ask a certified planner to itemize medical needs over decades: medication, injections, therapies, durable medical equipment, surgical intervals, home health. An economist then calculates present value using conservative discount rates that withstand Daubert challenges. The defense will lowball costs and inflate discount rates; we meet them with peer-reviewed data.
Settlement bracketing lets both sides test ranges without committing. If we tell a carrier we believe the jury range sits between $900,000 and $1.4 million, we’re signaling where we’ll settle and where we’ll try the case. Early case valuation meetings with mediators provide hard feedback. Good mediators know local verdict tendencies and will reality-test both sides’ blind spots.
The leverage moments that move offers
Cases shift when new risks appear. A deposition where the driver admits he “probably” missed his last break. A dispatcher email that contradicts the company’s safety manual. A treating surgeon whose credentials dwarf the defense expert’s and who testifies clearly on causation. Those inflection points don’t happen by accident. We plan them.
Discovery sequences can be the fulcrum. We often depose the safety director before the driver, to lock in admissions about policy and training. If the safety director concedes they track hard braking events and coach drivers who show patterns, the driver’s deposition becomes a credibility test: did coaching happen, and if not, why? The mismatch can push an adjuster to reserve upward.
Timing matters. Carriers hold tight until they must adjust reserves, usually after key depositions, expert designations, or the court’s denial of summary judgment on liability. A McKinney auto accident lawyer who knows the docket will set hearings at strategic points to maximize attention from the carrier’s higher-ups.
Example scenarios and numbers
It helps to see how this all plays out. Consider three common truck-injury patterns and how valuation can diverge.
A rear-end collision on 75 near Eldorado, clear liability, with a middle-aged office worker. ER visit shows cervical strain. MRI later reveals a C5-6 disc protrusion touching the cord. After months of conservative care, a pain specialist performs two epidural steroid injections with partial relief. No surgery recommended, but the client reports intermittent numbness and avoids heavy lifting. Medical paid amounts total about $38,000. Lost wages run $6,500. With credible testimony and clean prior medical history, this case may value in the $125,000 to $250,000 range depending on the client’s functional limitations, doctor support on causation, and venue tendencies.
A T-bone at a frontage road intersection when the truck makes a wide right turn and clips a passing vehicle. Liability is contested under a blind-spot theory, and there’s some argument the client was moving quickly to beat a light. Client is a 29-year-old electrician with a SLAP tear in the shoulder, arthroscopic repair, and a good but not perfect recovery. Medical paid amounts are $72,000. Past lost earnings are $18,000, with a vocational opinion that the client will lose heavy-elevation capacity over time. If comparative fault risk sits around 20 percent and the treating orthopedist supports permanence, a realistic settlement window might be $250,000 to $450,000, with larger numbers possible if corporate negligence (like unsafe delivery windows) comes into evidence.
A high-speed underride on 380 involving a fatigued driver drifting lanes. Client suffers multiple fractures, a mild TBI with cognitive deficits, and visible facial scarring. Medical paid amounts exceed $350,000, life-care plan projects $1.2 to $1.6 million in future costs, and a neuropsychologist documents lasting executive function impairment. The carrier has $1 million primary and $5 million excess. If liability is strong and defense experts can’t undercut the TBI diagnosis, the case lives in the seven-figure space. Settlements of $2 million to $5 million are achievable; trial results can go higher if jurors react strongly to safety violations and poor corporate oversight.
These are examples, not promises. They’re meant to show how a McKinney personal injury lawyer runs the calculation in the real world: liability first, medical clarity second, economic and non-economic damages integrated, and the insurance chessboard always in view.
The role of prior medical history and gaps in care
Carriers fixate on two things: prior injuries and treatment gaps. You don’t lose value just because you had a sore neck five years ago or a chiropractic course after a fender bender. You lose value if your current providers can’t distinguish the new injury from the old. We arm them with context: imaging comparisons, symptom timelines, and statements from people who can describe pre-crash function. The legal standard is aggravation — the defendant takes the victim as found. If a crash worsened a preexisting condition, that worsening is compensable.
Gaps in care cut both ways. Life happens. Clients miss appointments because they can’t afford copays or they think they’re improving until they’re not. We document the why. We also push for steady, appropriate treatment because juries read gaps as recovery. A defense expert with a calendar and a pen can make a four-week gap look like a cure unless the record explains it.
Settlement timing: when to hold and when to fold
A case matures when the medical picture stabilizes. Settling before maximum medical improvement is risky because you’re guessing. On the other hand, waiting for a surgery that might be years away can be impractical if liability is shaky or the client needs funds. We often set decision points: finish a course of injections, get a surgical consult, take the driver’s deposition. After those milestones, we reassess settlement value and decide whether to mediate.
Mediation isn’t a magic wand. It works best when both sides have enough information to price risk. A good mediator in Collin County will push each side off their anchor numbers and test the weaker parts of the case. We go in with a bottom-line strategy based on net recovery, not just headline figures.
Practical steps clients can take to protect value
- See the right doctors early and follow through. Missing the window for early imaging or specialty referrals can muddy causation and lower offers. Preserve evidence you control. Photograph injuries over time, keep damaged personal items, and save correspondence with employers about missed work. Be careful with social media. Innocent photos can be twisted; a single post of you smiling at a family event becomes Exhibit A for “no pain.” Tell your providers the whole truth. If you had prior back pain, disclose it. Hidden history hurts credibility more than the history itself. Track expenses and life changes. A simple journal of pain levels, activities you skip, and milestones you miss makes non-economic damages real.
How a McKinney lawyer’s local knowledge changes outcomes
Local knowledge is leverage. A McKinney car accident lawyer who tries cases in Collin County knows how jurors react to national trucking brands versus small local carriers, and how judges rule on evidence of corporate negligence. We know which orthopedists and neurologists communicate clearly in deposition and which physical therapy clinics generate records insurers respect. We understand the rhythms of the 219th or 401st District Court calendars, how long it takes to get a hearing, and how to keep pressure on a carrier that would prefer to wait you out.
Relationships matter without compromising independence. When you’ve deposed the same defense expert three times in other cases, you understand the angles he’ll take and how to box him in. When a claims manager knows you try cases, “we’ll see you in court” is not a bluff.
Why truck cases justify deeper investment
Some clients ask why we hire so many experts or chase so much data. Two reasons. First, the stakes justify it. Truck collisions cause life-changing harm more often than other crashes. Second, carriers invest heavily on their side. They dispatch rapid-response teams within hours, sometimes minutes, to preserve their version of events. If we don’t match that intensity, value bleeds away quietly.
A robust case can involve an accident reconstructionist, a human factors expert, a trucking safety expert who knows FMCSA regs cold, a vocational expert, a life-care planner, and an economist. Not every case needs the full roster, but we decide based on return on investment. Spending $20,000 on experts to move a case by $200,000 is smart advocacy.
The settlement number at the end of the spreadsheet
When it’s time to pick a number, we don’t just throw a multiplier at medical bills. We stack the elements: past medical paid amounts we can defend; future medical with ranges based on surgeon input; past lost wages with documentation; future earning capacity discounted to present value; non-economic damages grounded in credible testimony; and, if warranted, punitive exposure tied to gross negligence, though those are rare and tightly circumscribed under Texas law.
We then apply settlement realities: comparative fault risk, venue tendencies, credibility strength, and insurance structure. We run best case, mid case, and worst case projections. If trial costs are high and excess insurance is thin, our settlement target might slide. If a judge just let in damning corporate conduct evidence, our target might harden.
Contact Us
Thompson Law
Address: 321 N Central Expy STE 305, McKinney, TX 75071
Phone: (214) 390-9737